The hero image of mobile 360-v2

What Is 50/50 Fault in a Florida Car Accident?

In a 50/50 car insurance claim, each driver is found equally at fault. Under Florida’s comparative fault law, each driver can still recover damages from the other, but each driver’s award is cut by 50 percent. Your own PIP coverage still pays toward your medical bills, up to its limits, no matter who caused the crash.

What does 50/50 fault mean in Florida?

Comparative fault is a legal rule that splits responsibility for a crash into percentages. Each driver is assigned a share of the blame, and those shares add up to 100 percent. A 50/50 finding means each driver is treated as half responsible.

Under section 768.81(2), Florida Statutes, your share of fault reduces the amount you are awarded for both economic and noneconomic damages, but it does not bar your claim. There is one major limit. Under section 768.81(6), a person found greater than 50 percent at fault for their own harm may not recover any damages. That rule does not apply to medical negligence cases.

This is called modified comparative negligence. Florida adopted it in House Bill 837 (chapter 2023-15, Laws of Florida), which took effect March 24, 2023, and it applies to negligence cases filed after that date. Before that change, Florida used pure comparative negligence. Under the old rule, a person could be 99 percent at fault for their injuries in a car crash and still collect 1 percent of their damages from the other driver. That is no longer the law for new cases.

At exactly 50 percent, you are not more than 50 percent at fault, so you can still recover half of your damages.

How does 50/50 fault change what I can recover?

All of your damages, including medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering, are reduced by your percentage of fault. If you were 50 percent at fault, your damages are reduced by 50 percent.

For example, say the crash caused $10,000 in medical bills, $5,000 in lost wages, and $10,000 in pain and suffering. Your total damages would be $25,000. Here is how different fault findings change the result:

Your share of fault Total damages Amount you can recover
0 percent $25,000 $25,000
20 percent $25,000 $20,000
50 percent $25,000 $12,500
51 percent $25,000 $0 (recovery is barred)

This is why a few percentage points can matter so much. Moving from 50 percent to 51 percent fault can be the difference between half of your damages and nothing.

How does PIP work in a 50/50 accident?

Florida’s no-fault system means your own personal injury protection (PIP) coverage pays first, whoever caused the crash. Under section 627.736(1), Florida Statutes, PIP pays 80 percent of reasonable medical expenses and 60 percent of lost income, up to a $10,000 limit. To use PIP medical benefits, you must get initial care within 14 days after the crash.

A claim against the other driver for pain and suffering is a separate step. Under section 627.737(2), Florida Statutes, you can recover pain and suffering in a car crash case only if the injury involves significant and permanent loss of an important bodily function, a permanent injury, significant and permanent scarring or disfigurement, or death. When you qualify, that award is also reduced by your share of fault.

What is a common 50/50 car accident example?

This is the comparative fault example we see most often. You are driving and come up to a four way stop. At the same time, the driver to your right comes to the same four way stop. You both stop, then both start through the intersection, each thinking the other driver stayed at the stop sign. There are no other cars or witnesses around. You and the other driver collide in a T-bone style crash in the middle of the intersection.

Who is at fault? The likely answer is that each driver will be found 50 percent at fault. The same idea applies in many other situations with many different percentages, which is why it helps to talk with a Tampa car accident lawyer before you accept a fault decision.

Do you fall into one of these situations?

  1. Law enforcement gave you a ticket for the car accident, and you were hurt in that accident.
  2. The insurance company decided you were at fault for the crash, and you were hurt in that crash.

If either situation describes you, Franchi Law wants to talk with you. A ticket or an adjuster’s opinion is not the final word on fault.

Who decides fault after a Florida car accident?

Many people assume the police decide fault. They do not decide it for your injury claim. An officer may write a crash report and issue a ticket, but Florida law limits how those can be used in court:

So who decides fault? Either the insurance companies, through the claims process, or a jury, if the case goes to trial. Our personal injury lawyers are prepared to deal with both.

Why doesn’t law enforcement decide fault? Most of the time, officers do not see the crash happen. William Franchi, our founding attorney, is a former deputy. From that experience, he knows how hard it is to fully investigate a crash while higher priority calls are waiting and there is pressure to finish a “minor” crash quickly.

How do we investigate a disputed fault claim?

When Franchi Law is hired after a car crash with injuries, we start an investigation. A car accident attorney reviews the facts first. Then we decide whether a crash reconstruction expert is needed. Many cars on the road today have an event data recorder, which is similar to an airplane’s black box. If the data could help, we work to have it collected and reviewed. This gives us the evidence needed to challenge the insurance company’s version of events.

Our guide on how to collect evidence after a car accident explains what you can do on your own to protect your claim.

How do insurance companies use 50/50 fault to pay less?

When both drivers share some blame, insurance companies often try to shift a higher percentage of fault onto the injured person. Because Florida now bars recovery above 50 percent fault, an insurer that can push you from 50 percent to 51 percent may owe you nothing. Here are common tactics and how a lawyer can respond.

Assigning you a higher percentage of fault

The insurer may argue you were more responsible than the evidence shows. For example, it might claim you were speeding or did not fully stop at a stop sign.

How a lawyer can help: A lawyer can gather evidence such as witness statements, photos, and accident reconstruction reports to argue for a fair percentage of fault.

Using your statements to shift blame

After a crash, an adjuster may ask for a recorded statement, hoping you will say something that shifts more fault onto you.

How a lawyer can help: Your lawyer can guide you through any statement, or handle communication for you, so your words are not used to raise your percentage of fault.

Downplaying your injuries and damages

Insurers sometimes argue that your injuries are less serious than claimed, or that your medical bills do not reflect the real impact of the injury.

How a lawyer can help: An attorney can compile detailed records of your medical bills, lost wages, and other damages to show the full impact of the injury.

Delaying settlement offers

Some insurers delay a claim to pressure the injured person into a lower offer, especially when medical costs and lost income are adding up.

How a lawyer can help: A lawyer can press the insurer to move the claim forward and, if needed, file a lawsuit.

Offering a low settlement early

In a 50/50 situation, an insurer may make a low offer early to discourage you from pursuing the claim.

How a lawyer can help: Your attorney can compare the offer to your total damages, after any reduction for your share of fault, and negotiate for a settlement that reflects your actual losses.

Different states follow different rules, such as contributory negligence, pure comparative negligence, or modified comparative negligence. Florida now follows modified comparative negligence, so the fault percentage is often the most important number in your claim.

Should I talk to the insurance company before talking to a lawyer?

It is important to talk to a personal injury attorney about your car crash before you give the insurance company a recorded statement. If you had been arrested, would you rather talk to the police with or without a lawyer? Most people would choose to have a lawyer. The insurance company is no different. The adjuster’s job is to limit what the company pays.

Talk with a Tampa comparative fault lawyer

If you were hurt in a car accident in Tampa or Riverview and you are being blamed for part of it, call Franchi Law at (813) 800-4529. The consultation is free, and there are no legal fees unless we recover money for you. You can also learn more about our Riverview car accident lawyers and our Riverview personal injury attorneys.

Tampa office: 4100 W Kennedy Blvd, Suite 300, Tampa, FL 33609. Riverview office: 11131 Winthrop Market St, Suite C, Riverview, FL 33578.

Frequently Asked Questions

What happens in a 50/50 car insurance claim in Florida?

Each driver is treated as half responsible for the crash. Each driver can still recover damages from the other, but each award is reduced by 50 percent. Your own PIP coverage still pays toward medical bills and lost income, up to its limits, regardless of fault.

Can I recover damages if I was partly at fault for a car accident in Florida?

Yes, as long as you are not more than 50 percent at fault. Under section 768.81, Florida Statutes, your damages are reduced by your share of fault. If you are found greater than 50 percent at fault for your own harm, you cannot recover damages, except in medical negligence cases.

What happens if I am found 51 percent at fault?

Under Florida’s modified comparative negligence rule, a person found greater than 50 percent at fault for their own harm may not recover any damages. That rule applies to negligence cases filed after March 24, 2023. This is why evidence that lowers your share of fault matters.

Does a traffic ticket mean I was at fault for the accident?

No. A ticket is not the final word on fault in an injury claim. Under section 316.650(9), Florida Statutes, traffic citations are not admissible as evidence in any trial, with narrow exceptions. Fault is decided by the insurance companies during the claim or by a jury.

How long do I have to file a car accident lawsuit in Florida?

For most negligence claims that arose after March 24, 2023, the deadline is two years under section 95.11(5)(a), Florida Statutes. Other deadlines can apply in some cases, so speak with a lawyer as soon as possible.